Skip to main content
Promotional banner ad for the Penetration Testing Report Kit
5 Myths That Keep Compliance Officers From Getting HelpGovernance & Workforce
5 min readFor Compliance Officers

5 Myths That Keep Compliance Officers From Getting Help

You know how records move through an organization. You've traced a claim from intake to payment, mapped who can see a diagnosis code, and written the retention schedule. That fluency can backfire. When the job starts to wear you down, the same habit that makes you good at your work can make a first call to a therapist feel riskier than it is.

These myths persist because they're half true. Records do travel. Employers do see some things. The gap is between "some risk exists" and "any step toward care is career-ending." Here's where the fear outruns the facts.

Myth 1: "Burnout is just a rough quarter. Real compliance people push through."

Reality: The World Health Organization describes burnout in the International Classification of Diseases as an occupational phenomenon with three features: exhaustion, growing mental distance or cynicism about the job, and reduced professional efficacy.

In compliance, it rarely looks like slacking. It looks like more work: rereading the same policy section several times before signing off, over-checking work that's already correct, letting investigations and corrective action plans stay open longer than they need to, waking at 3 a.m. with a running list of open items, or quietly concluding that nothing the program does matters.

Any one of these can be ordinary. Several together, for weeks, deserve the attention you'd give a repeat audit finding. You wouldn't close that finding with "push through."

Myth 2: "HIPAA will protect whatever I tell my employer or what sits in my HR file."

Reality: The HIPAA Privacy Rule governs how Covered Entities (health plans, health care providers, and clearinghouses) use and disclose Protected Health Information (PHI). It doesn't reach every record an employer holds. HHS states that the Privacy Rule "does not protect your employment records, even if the information in those records is health-related."

That has practical consequences. Your employer can ask for a doctor's note. A provider, though, can't hand your employer health information without your authorization. Once a note, leave request, or accommodation form lands in your personnel file, HIPAA is no longer the control governing it. Your organization's policies, and other laws, are.

Myth 3: "If I use the company health plan, my manager can see my diagnosis."

Reality: Where an employer sponsors a group health plan, the plan documents must provide that the sponsor will "not use or disclose the information for employment-related actions and decisions" (45 CFR 164.504(f)). That's a required firewall between plan data and employment decisions.

Here's the uncomfortable part. In a self-funded plan, maintaining that firewall is often part of your own job. So the honest question isn't "does the rule exist?" It's "how well does the firewall hold where I work?" Check who in your organization can access plan data, how that access is documented, and whether the plan documents contain the required language. If you can't answer those questions, you've just found a control gap, and you can fix it for everyone, not only for yourself.

Myth 4: "Therapy notes are the same as the claim record, so everything is equally protected."

Reality: They're different, and the difference matters. Under 45 CFR 164.508(a)(2), a Covered Entity generally must obtain the patient's authorization before using or disclosing psychotherapy notes, with narrow exceptions. Those are a therapist's separately kept session notes.

The claim, the diagnosis code, and the dates of service are not psychotherapy notes. They travel with billing. If you submit through your employer's plan, that claim data exists, even though the plan sponsor is walled off from it for employment purposes.

Employee assistance programs vary widely. Ask the vendor, in writing, exactly what it reports to the employer and at what level of detail. The contract is the answer, not an assumption.

Myth 5: "Asking for help will show up on a form someday and cost me my credentials."

Reality: This fear is real, and it's documented. In a national sample of 5,829 physicians, nearly 40 percent said they'd be reluctant to seek formal care for a mental health condition because of concerns about repercussions to their medical licensure. Reluctance was higher in states whose licensing applications asked about more than current impairment (Dyrbye and colleagues, Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 2017).

Notice what drove the fear: the wording of the forms. Questions about past treatment make people wait; questions about current impairment don't have the same chilling effect. You're not a physician, but the mechanism transfers. If you hold a professional certification or sit for credentialing, read exactly what the attestation asks. Then look at your own organization's credentialing questions, attestations, and leave forms. Reviewing them for that distinction is squarely within your reach.

What to Do Instead

Replace the vague fear with a short assessment, the way you'd scope any risk.

  1. Put confidentiality in writing. Give staff a plain-language statement of what the organization can and can't see when an employee uses the health plan or the employee assistance program.
  2. Set after-hours boundaries. Define what truly needs a call at night and route everything else to the next business day.
  3. Build a peer link outside the building. A trusted compliance colleague at another organization can hear what you can't say internally.
  4. Choose care that fits your privacy needs. Some professionals prefer telehealth, a clinician outside their professional circle, or paying privately so no claim reaches the employer's plan. None of these is required; they're options.
  5. Audit the forms. Check credentialing questions, attestations, and leave forms for past-treatment wording versus current-impairment wording.
  6. Know the crisis line. If you or someone on your team is in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

You protect everyone else's records for a living. Apply the same clear thinking to your own. Knowing what the Privacy Rule covers, where it stops, and which questions to ask turns a vague fear into a manageable risk. Managing risk is the work you already do well.

Promotional banner highlighting failures found in PCI audits and how to spot the gaps

You Might Also Like